jonthomson's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[madness combat in real life]

It's a little bit different, so I'll give you a protect as it's at least a little bit quirky, still the same old thing though

[Madness Test Animation 3 RE]

Madness Day or no Madness Day, if it's a test it's incomplete and shouldn't be uploaded.

[Madness Incident]

Meh. It's a bunch of Madness guys shooting each other. It has some length, has some backgrounds and is generally well animated with backgrounds, sounds and everything, but it's not anything that Krinkels didn't do better a decade ago. Make your own characters and ideas with the skills you have and you'll do far better rather than swimming in a sea of shit ripoffs.

StHeromax responds:

Yeah, I know that the animtion has no plot at all, but I already have some ideas to realize, characters and a lot of things that I want to do, but I can't because of low skill. Of coarse, I won't stop only on idea that some mad guys are shooting each other without any reason. Next time I will try to make some plot before to make fights look at least less pointless.

[#Flip challenge]

So after we cut through the intro, which takes up half the length of the movie, we just have some Madness guys doing uninteresting things. Boring and unoriginal. At least it has OK sound and isn't just a plain background, but if you'd have used your own characters and made the movie actually 25-30 seconds rather than 10 you'd score a lot higher.

[Fight Scene 2]

It's not bad I guess, Looks quite nice and the animation's alright, decent if limited sounds, it's just a bit on the short side with not much happening.

[Sanford the Table Basher]

Generic 4 second Krinkels ripoff. Has a bit of a better framerate than most similar things uploaded here and you've at least put a background in, but it's still 4 seconds, it's not your ideas, and it's not something we haven't seen thousands of times before. Something a bit longer with your own ideas gets protected.

MAnimationsNStuff responds:

hey how about i upload it again but more different
also i practiced alot before i actually uploaded this

[Madness: broken]

Generic Krinkels ripoff. It's got a bit of length, but the framerate is real poor, there's no coherent story, it's just some Madness guy shooting people until he gets shot. Nothing really new to see here, it's just about protectable as it's a bit better than a lot of similar junk that gets uploaded but it's basically just for the die hard Madness fans and that's it.

[Madness STARTER 3 guard takedown]

Animation and framerate looks good but if you can't think of your own characters it needs to be a lot more interesting and longer than six seconds of Madness guys shooting each other, it's nothing we haven't seen thousands of times before.