jonthomson's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[CaptainCarbonara Loop]

Decent enough short loop, I like the music and graphical style, quite cleverly done as a loop.

SuperPhil64 responds:

Thanks, glad you liked it!

[Fatsack: BWDS ep 1]

OK little short with some very nice graphics and animation, and I like the style, it just doesn't do enough for me - there's no story and having a quarter of the movie be credits seems excessive.

chluaid responds:

They're very short because my rule for this series is that each script fits on a collector card. Those cards are Patreon rewards.

[Jamie Speed Paint]

Boring video that shows us nothing interesting, only something that at the end should go straight to the art portal, and lame youtube spam in the comments to boot.

LittleWolfie responds:

Gee thanks :( i try tho.....

[Trashman]

Not a bad little short. Interesting animation style, worth the quick look. Could really have used some sound though.

PencilPals responds:

We appreciate your critique! This was our first animation, next time we'll include audio too!

[Madness: Zombifacation PREVIEW]

Do not submit contentless previews to the Portal. This is telling us nothing about your movie other than there's a load of Madness guys killing each other, which we've all seen a million times before. Quit now and come up with your own ideas.

Sherklov responds:

Wow. I did not expect that. So, what you're saying is that I should just abandon this entire project?

[madness original 1]

Unoriginal Madness rubbish, is on a never ending loop, loop is only about 10 seconds to begin with, info bars at the top and bottom obstruct large portions of the screen. Come up with your own ideas and make it at least five times longer and it might be worth protecting.

MFC-CFJ responds:

Thank for your help= = this animation just a tast

[LoL - Love it when you ward]

Incredibly dull short, animation levels are quite limited, try not churning out two of these a day and start putting effort into them if you want to get any sort of decent ratings.

Rixian responds:

Thank you :'D (This isn't sarcasm, it's genuine thanks)